Masters of light opera and the pastiche and parody of the 19th
Century British class systems, Gilbert & Sullivan wrote many productions
which played on ridiculing the foundations of the Empirical society and, as
such, were loved throughout the world.
Their clever word play, lampooning of classical works and of
course, catchy tunes made them a must-see for theatre goers from the late
eighteen hundreds right up to the modern day. It is widely accepted that
they are a staple favourite for AmDram companies across the world, giving great
scope for visual humour to compliment the lyrical joviality which runs through
all of their operettas.
Whilst I am aware of many of their 'hit' numbers, I have to
admit that I was a G&S virgin and so last nights production of
"Gilbert & Sullivan Abridged" was to be my first true
experience. What I saw however left me baffled and quite unsure as to
whether G & S are really for me.
The premise of the show is an AmDram production, (well 3
actors) taking their G & S review on tour to raise funds for their
austerity-hit theatre. The intention, I believe, is to take the audience on a
journey through the greatest works of the much-loved duo with renditions of
their greatest tunes and explanations behind their operatic story-telling.
What transpired was 2 acts of parlour renditions accompanied by a pre-recorded
piano and punctuated by a nonsensical recounting of an 'orphaned' boy looking
for his mother. Speaking to many G & S aficionados at the interval
they kindly explained that many of the operas' in-jokes were lost as key
songs were delivered in isolation with none of the pretence or narrative needed
to give the witticisms their substance.
Ask anyone about Gilbert & Sullivan and they will most
likely remark on their extremely witty word play delivered in tongue-twisting
speed and operatic variety - indeed it was this Anglicising of traditional
Italian opera that set them apart and created a much loved following - simply
listening to the phrasing in " The Modern Major General" is
great example of the vocal dexterity demanded by their works. The
tolerance for error is therefore minuscule, miss one word or beat and the whole
verse is lost - it is a must that whomsoever tackles these songs is
blessed with flexibility of tongue and elasticity of mouth. Sadly this
was not the case and many of the headline numbers were lost in stumbled
mumblings and frantic catch ups. When coupled with off key harmonies and a
stuttering use of props the show resembled more the out-takes from an early Monty
Python rehearsal session (apologies to Messrs Cleese, Palin et al); as for
the ill-advised and mis-placed inclusion of a street rapper, well some cultures
are just meant to stay far apart.
I expected an evening of discovery which would stimulate my
desire to seek out more G & S works, what I got was very 'Am' much less
'Dram' and sadly worse than most X-Factor auditions - for me it was a
No! If you already love G & S, or have a passing interest than
I suggest you seek out a full production of one of their operas and experience
their wonderfully clever, erudtite and astute writings as it is meant to be.